I did a closing yesterday for a title company. I have worked with this company many times. They make mistakes, but I'm able to catch them so that things work out.
They made a mistake with this closing. They left a document out of the package. The documents were all sent together in one file, so there is no chance that I neglected to print one of the attachments. It's really not the mistake they made that bothers me, but the way they handled it.
If you need a document signed, and it's urgent, the most efficient way to contact the notary signing agent is by cell phone. Not by email, which is how they notified me. I don't sit at a desk all day. I'm on the road. If someone sends me an email at 12 noon, I might not see it until 12 midnight. So a lot of time was wasted by the way they notified me.
Also, the way they worded the email, it makes it look like the signing agent neglected to do something. Here is the email:
Anyone who understands the English language might get the impression that it was a notary signing agent error. When they read: the document "did not make it back", it appears that the document was misplaced, or that the signing agent failed to have it signed. I don't know. Maybe the document left the package on its own and decided it didn't want to go back. Okay, I'm being facetious. But there is no mention at all that the document was not included in the loan package. So how can a document "make it back" if it was never sent? I still have the file as proof.
I handled this as professionally as possible. I contacted the borrower this evening. I wasn't able to speak with him, but I left a message. I didn't blame the title company. I simply said that there is an additional document that needs to be signed, and I want to make arrangements to get it signed. As for the title company, I will let them know tomorrow that I expect to be compensated for making an additional trip. My policy is: get the job done first -- haggle about money later. Also, if I make the error, I correct it at my expense. If they make the error, they have to pay.
Will I work with this company again? Of course. Why not? No one is perfect. We all make mistakes.
But if you make a mistake, then come right out and say, in plain English, that you made a mistake. Don't mince words.

During the signing she wanted to stay around and watch her parents sign the loan documents. After a while she became impatient, just sitting there and watching. She got up and began doing gymnastics. Her mother told her not to. But she kept getting up and going through the motions as if she were going to do a cartwheel. I could sense that this was something she really wanted to do.
By the way, it was a very good cartwheel. I'll give it a 10.
"Readers" are borrowers who want to take their time and read everything: Closing instructions, notary instructions, ... even the FedEx shipping label. They want to read it.
And that is one of the reasons why I don't book my closings so close together. I want to be prepared for the possibility that I may encounter ... a "reader".
P.S. The only time that I have ever charged the borrower for cancelling a loan was the time I drove 40 miles to Pueblo to do a closing. The borrower's father was there. He convinced his daughter that the loan was a bad deal. She had a bunch of bear claws on the table. She felt bad about me driving all the way down there. I told her that it wasn't a problem. I told her that the only thing I'll charge her is one of those bear claws for my trip back to Colorado Springs. She gladly paid it.
I got a call this morning to notarize a Last Will and Testament. Whenever I get a request like this, there are a few things that I want to make sure of: there will be sufficient witnesses, and that the document has a notary certificate. This is an instance in which I will never add a loose certificate. I also want it to be known that I cannot give any kind of legal advice, and cannot assist in filling out the document.
To me it means that we should never become complacent and believe that we can't improve. Because we can. If you are doing something well, try to find ways to do it better. There are. And keep striving to improve. This way of thinking can be applied to all areas of our life.
Good luck, and never stop growing.